• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Honeypie Cafe: A Cozy Culinary Haven for Breakfast and Brunch Lovers

“Honeypie Cafe” in Milwaukee offers a cozy, modern diner vibe with delicious food and friendly staff. The menu boasts unique dishes like the breakfast casserole and the famous pie selection that customers rave about. With a focus on breakfast and brunch, this spot is a must-visit for foodies looking for a delightful dining experience. The breakfast casserole is a standout, layered with flavorful ingredients that make each bite a delight. Don’t miss out on the Salted Honey Pie or the Chocolate Hazelnut pie for a sweet ending to your meal. Overall, “Honeypie Cafe” delivers a memorable culinary experience that keeps customers coming back for more.

Honeypie Cafe at a glance

  • Address 2569 S Kinnickinnic Ave Milwaukee, WI 53207
  • Phone (414) 489-7437
  • Restaurant type Diner , Pie shop , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for breakfast , Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Honeypie Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Nisan E Arpali
5

We stopped by Honey Pie Dining for our first family breakfast takeout – busy morning, but worth the wait! Food was delicious, service was friendly. However, our pie was missing from the order. BUT, their exceptional customer service saved the day! The manager personally delivered the correct pie to our home, along with extra treats and a generous $20 gift card! Impressed by their kindness and dedication. We'll definitely return!

Scott Cherek
4

My first time visiting Honey Pie, in over 5 years. The atmosphere is soothing and inviting, almost like visiting a friend back in the day. I had the Bourbon Hound, which was a great pick. We ordered the Fried Cheese Curds - and wow, they are so fresh & squeaky! Mmmm... My Reuben & Truffle Fries were not great, for me. The Corned Beef was somewhat chewy. That's not good. I liked the rye bread and sauce, but this was a big miss for me for a Reuben. The truffle fries have good flavor, but seemed a bit over-salted. My wife had the Club Sandwich and fries and said slightly over salted a bit too, but still pretty good. My two sons had two sandwiches and both were good, so maybe skip the Reuben and you'll all be happy. Or maybe this, just not the Reuben's best showing. Nice place, good service, worth the visit.

Che Gomez
5

Since walking in the service was amazing. The bartender was welcoming and friendly. Our server, Bradley was a delight handling my food allergies, making recommendations and making us feel like royalty. Our Mocktails, appetizers and meal were delicious. If I could give 10 stars I would.

Jenna Kinney
4

Overall the dining experience was good! I went out of my comfort zone with the salmon dish and it was cooked very well. The coffee drinks were also tasty. I will be back for sure!

Private_Joke (Stretch)
5

It’s a treat to go there. Not a huge variety of breakfast or lunch options, but enough to find something good. I had the club sandwich was good. Fries were delicious. Wife had the burger and was happy. At least 20 pie variations. No banana cream pie though so we passed on pie The photo was after I started eating. I always forget to take pictures

Mari L
5

Loved my first experience at Honeypie after years of driving by. The decor, ambiance, service, and food were all great. The inside has a nostalgic and comforting, yet modern feel. Chicken and fresh toast was perfect. My friend really enjoyed the breakfast burrito. Will be back!

Valerie Smith
5

This place is super cute and the pie is amazing. I’ve visited a friend in town a few times and we ALWAYS hit up Honeypie. This time we ate breakfast at their house and then they decided we needed MORE breakfast. I was already stuffed so I just ordered the Salted Honey pie. It’s so sweet and I’m not usually a sweet person. But the caramelized crunchy honey top is reminiscent of crem brûlée and the whipped cream and crust are perfect to cut the sweetness. So good I forgot to take a picture before I started!

lexie porter
5

ADORABLE place with homey vibes in the seating and bar areas. AMAZING food and drinks with great service. Don't leave without a slice of pie! Walking in you immediately get the cute diner/cafe vibes with the pie case and artwork you're met with. We went around 2pm and we immediately got a seat and great service. I ordered the burger after a server recommendation and it was delicious. It was cooked perfectly and the toppings all melded together amazingly. We also ordered the corn muffins which had a hint of sweetness and were perfectly warm. Others ordered the Caesar salad, breakfast casserole, and the hopple popple scramble. Rave reviews for those as well. You get your moneys worth as well, there is LOTS of food in each option. We also got slices of the Chocolate Cream Pie and Salted Caramel Pie, so glad we did. The Chocolate was perfectly rich with great whipped cream. The salted caramel was one of the best cream pies ive ever had. The chocolate crust and whipped cream tied it together perfectly with almost a cheesecake vibe. SO YUMMY! -We have returned multiple times and its always amazing. The breakfast casserole is my all time favorite!

Location

  • Honeypie Cafe
    Honeypie Cafe
    2569 S Kinnickinnic Ave Milwaukee, WI 53207 Hotline: (414) 489-7437

Welcome to Honeypie Cafe, a cozy and trendy spot located in Milwaukee, WI, offering a delightful blend of New American cuisine, breakfast, brunch, and burgers. This unclaimed gem provides a variety of options to cater to everyone's tastes and dietary preferences, including vegan and vegetarian choices.

At Honeypie Cafe, you can enjoy the convenience of delivery, takeout, and reservations, while also being able to relax in their outdoor seating area. The ambiance is described as hipster and casual, with a moderate noise level, making it a great spot for groups, kids, or a relaxing brunch.

The reviews from satisfied customers speak for themselves, highlighting the friendly staff, delicious food, and charming atmosphere. Dishes like the breakfast casserole, beef hash, Denver omelette, and the mouth-watering pies, such as Salted Honey Pie and Chocolate Hazelnut, have left patrons raving about their dining experience.

If you're a fan of unique and flavorful dishes, generous portions, and top-notch service, Honeypie Cafe is definitely worth a visit. So why not treat yourself to a memorable meal at this delightful cafe?

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • On-site services available
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards